15/8/97

The triplet boom: Hard to conceive

   There's a family in Petah Tikva. The father's unemployed and they're on welfare. They had three children - one of them removed to a boarding school because of suspected child abuse.
Not a model family.
   You know what some brilliant doctor did for them? He gave them fertility drugs.
They had triplets.
   
Another Israeli couple: he's got cerebral palsy, she's disabled from myasthenia gravis. Hers is a grim, debilitating muscle disorder, and it's hereditary. They were struggling along with a nine-month-old baby when her gynecologist, with supreme wisdom, prescribed fertility drugs.
   
They had triplets.
   
A young Ra'anana couple: blessedly fertile. She wanted to alter her cycle for religious reasons. ג€œHere, take this,ג€ her doctor said. He gave her fertility drugs. Didn't explain what it was, she trusted him enough not to ask.
   
They had triplets.
   
A Jerusalem mother: Maybe her gynecologist woke up stupid that morning; he did not bother to ask some very basic questions, and prescribed treatment. Mind you, he was not unsuccessful: She did ovulate. Not just one egg, as is the norm, but 20 eggs. What the hell, he figured, let's see what happens if I implant five of 'em.
   
Triplets.
   
There's been an explosion of technologically engineered multiple births in this country - and throughout the Western world - in the past decade. Well over 500 Israeli families have borne children in bunches of three or more; nature accounts for about one-seventh of such births, science the rest.
   
Israel is believed to have the world's highest per-capita number of IVF centers producing test-tube babies; one city, Bnei Brak, has what may be the highest rate of multiple births in the world. There are at least 60 such families there: two with two sets of triplets each.
   
Many experts - none yet in Israel - have come to realize that fertility enhancement, even for a barren couple craving a baby, is a multiple predicament. In Britain, and a growing number of US states, it is now illegal to implant more than three eggs in IVF procedures, chancing that maybe one or two might take. Some experts feel even that is too many. Here, five are commonly implanted.
   
It is a multiple predicament indeed: Most such infants are born too early and too small. Serious medical problems are common, and keep many babies in intensive care for weeks or months. Some die; others are afflicted for life.
   
The cost is enormous: in economic terms for the state, in the strain on medical facilities, and in emotional trauma for the families.
   
US figures show incidence of child abuse in families with multiples is higher.
   
Even in the best of circumstances, when the babies are all healthy, it is usually too much of a good thing: Families struggle for years. Marital counseling becomes the norm, and the incidence of breakups is high. In some cases, even mothers have fled.
   
Associations for triplet families worldwide, including Israel's Triplets Plus, have as many horror stories to tell as happy ones.
   
Expectant parents are often forced to make a decision that torments them for life. The doctor, having recklessly over-implanted, may then offer the staggered couple a grisly choice: kill some of the growing embryos, or risk losing them all.
   
Well, what would you decide?
   
It's a matter of scientific complacency: The procedure is routine for the practitioner; for his patient, the result is immensely fateful. The scientist's concern is how to make babies, not how to raise them. If he conjures up a batch, he has succeeded; if the parents can't cope, it's their failure.
   
One of the world's foremost fertility experts, Dr. Robert Winston of London, clamors vociferously for ethical considerations to wrest precedence from technological egoism.
   
Couples should be counseled before starting treatment; three babies at once is a brutal burden; limited failure is preferable to excess success.
   
In Israel, families with multiples are better off than in most countries. Governmental aid is comparatively generous, with both the Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs and National Insurance Institute chipping in. But it's a limited pie, and as more and more families claim a slice, the inevitable happens: Last year, in both Dimona and Jerusalem, the money ran out by September. Desperately needed payments were abruptly stopped.
   
(And then, there are always the perils of bureaucracy: One NII clerk showed astounding insensitivity to an expectant Negev father inquiring about assistance. ג€œAsk me again next month,ג€ she barked back, ג€œif all three babies are still alive.ג€)
  
Israeli lobbyists for controlled fertility treatment find little sympathy, in large part because this country is mad about children: If one is a blessing, three are three blessings. Even if it is, shall we say, a blessing disguised.
   
One mother gave birth to triplets. Two have Down's. ג€œI thank God that two of them have it,ג€ she said, ג€œbecause theyג€™ll always have each other.ג€