1/9/97
Off
the
Wall
Nothing
like
a
traditional
bar
mitzva,
marshmallows
and
all.
When
Rabbi
Jay
Karzen
made
aliya
from
Chicago
in
1985,
he
discovered
that
the
last
thing
the
Jewish
State
needs
is
rabbis.
Fortunately,
he
is
just
the
right
kind
of
rabbi
to
make
his
mark
here:
unorthodox
Orthodox.
Sure
enough,
a
year
later,
he
found
his
calling.
He
couldn't
help
but
notice
the
balagan
(mayhem)
at
the
Wall,
which
for
locals
might
be
a
way
of
life,
but
for
visiting
families
conscripting
their
children
into
Jewish
adulthood,
well,
something
had
to
be
done.
The
Bar
Mitzva
King
was
born.
He
called
his
shtick
Rituals
Unlimited,
never
realizing
that
hundreds
of
rituals
later,
he'd
be
writing
a
book
on
the
"unlimited"
part
of
it.
He's
been
asked
to
fulfill
some
of
the
darndest
requests
you
can
imagine.
Like
the
75-year-old
man
who
wanted
a
bar
mitzva
...
to
please
his
95-year-old
mother.
Some
of
the
letters
he's
received
suggest
that
there
are
Jewish
youngsters
(he
also
does
a
nice
bat
mitzva)
who
might
just
as
well
be
summoned
to
the
Torah
in
Disneyland.
An
Arab
beigele
vendor
at
Dung
Gate
understands
more
about
Judaism,
and
the
Wall,
and
bar
mitzvas,
than
a
fair
slice
of
Diaspora
Jewry.
Rabbi
Karzen
assures
us
all
these
letters
are
real
(I
assure
you
his
responses
were
a
lot
more
diplomatic
than
my
suggestions
hereunder)
....
"We
would
like
to
decorate
our
side
of
the
mehitza
fence
with
balloons
and/or
flowers,
to
make
it
look
more
festive.
Is
this
a
problem?"
A
problem?
Nah.
Regulars
at
the
Wall
have
long
been
saying
the
place
needs
a
bit
of
oomph.
Maybe
you
can
bring
some
Christmas
decorations?
"We
hear
that
most
of
the
men
wear
black
velvet
skullcaps
at
the
Wall.
We
prefer
blue
and
intend
to
bring
satin
kipot
with
our
son's
name
and
date
on
them.
Is
this
acceptable
and
will
the
ultra-Orthodox
make
fun
of
us
if
we
wear
yarmulkas
of
a
different
color
and
fabric?"
I
assure
you
the
ultra-Orthodox,
who
are
avowedly
not
clothes-conscious,
will
be
deeply
moved
by
it
all.
In
fact,
I
suggest
you
bring
an
extra
supply
of
blue
satin
kipot
for
them
to
wear
too.
And
we'll
tell
them
to
wear
their
blue
suits.
"We
expect
a
very
large
crowd
at
the
Western
Wall
for
our
simcha.
Can
you
please
arrange
to
book
the
entire
Kotel
for
this
event.
We
are
prepared
to
pay
whatever
it
costs."
Consider
it
done.
I
know
of
an
abandoned
disco
downtown,
we
can
redirect
the
other
worshippers
there
for
the
day.
Nobody
will
mind.
PS:
There's
an
ATM
automatic
teller
imbedded
in
the
Wall,
for
your
convenience.
"For
our
invitations
we
need
to
know
exact
address
of
the
Kotel."
The
Wall,
3842-A
The
Holy
One
Blessed
Be
He
Boulevard
West,
Suite
2428,
al-Quds.
"We
are
not
a
particularly
religious
family.
Is
it
possible
to
have
a
non-religious
BM
ceremony
at
the
Wall?"
Why
sure!
A
religious
ceremony
is
not
the
only
way
to
induct
a
blushing
boy
into
manhood.
"Here
in
the
USA
all
sets
of
tefillin
we
see
at
the
local
bookstores
and
Sisterhood
Gift
Shoppes
are
all
BLACK.
Can
tefillin
be
blue
or
some
other
bright
color?
We
would
prefer
something
more
festive
than
black!
After
all
this
is
a
Simcha!"
When
you
get
to
Israel,
I'll
take
you
to
a
Black
Sisterhood
Gift
Shoppe,
where
all
the
tefillin
are
white.
"Can
you
rent
tefillin
in
Israel?
We
do
not
wish
to
purchase
this
expensive
item
for
one
time
usage."
A
pair
of
tefillin
is
standard
equipment
with
all
rent-a-cars
in
Israel.
"Our
son
does
not
attend
religious
school
and
cannot
read
any
Hebrew.
Can
you
conduct
an
all-English
bar
mitzva
service
for
us?"
A
cinch.
We'll
just
use
the
original
English
version
of
the
Torah,
and
not
the
Hebrew
translation.
"Jason's
birthday
is
in
November
but
we
can
only
come
to
Israel
during
the
summer
vacation.
Is
it
permissible
to
advance
the
ceremony
a
few
months?
Can
you
be
flexible
and
stretch
the
law
a
bit?
After
all,
isn't
it
more
important
for
a
Jewish
youngster
to
have
his
first
aliya
in
Jerusalem
a
few
months
early
than
not
at
all?
(We
could
have
lied
and
told
you
he
was
already
13.)"
I
could
go
to
Rabbinical
Prison
for
that.
Tell
you
what
we'll
do.
You
say
he'll
be
12
years
old?
We'll
give
him
a
bat
mitzva
instead.
"We
will
be
part
of
an
organized
tour
group
and
want
to
have
a
simple
early
morning
bar
mitzva
service
in
order
to
be
back
at
the
hotel
for
breakfast
and
not
miss
the
day's
tour.
Can
we
have
a
6:30
a.m.
service
(abbreviated)?
Do
we
get
a
discount
for
a
shorter
service?"
Or
you
could
skip
the
hotel
breakfast,
ask
them
for
a
discount,
and
I'll
arrange
for
rabbis
at
the
Kotel
to
serve
coffee
and
danish.
"We
plan
to
write
prayers
to
place
inside
the
Kotel,
as
is
the
tradition.
Can
these
prayers
be
written
in
English
or
must
they
be
only
in
Hebrew?"
I'm
afraid
the
English
translator
is
on
vacation
at
present.
Can
you
write
them
in
Aramaic?
"Please
order
a
large
sign
with
our
family
name
for
the
Kotel
so
that
when
the
guests
arrive
they
will
be
able
to
locate
us
easily."
Are
you
in
luck.
They've
just
installed
a
great
new
electronic
cartoony
kind
of
stadium
scoreboard
on
the
Kotel.
We
can
program
it
to
flash
messages
like
"Yo!
Gerald's
bar
mitzva
guests!
Over
here
by
the
hotdog
stand!"
"We
are
preparing
the
Torah
honors
list
to
bring
with
us.
Can
a
non-Jew
have
a
non-speaking
honor
during
the
Torah
service
(i.e.
opening
the
Ark
curtain
or
doors)???
Will
it
be
offensive
to
you
if
we
give
such
an
honor
to
a
Jew
who
is
agnostic?"
I'm
afraid
this
would
not
be
allowed.
They
will
have
to
convert.
Fortunately
your
bar
mitzva
package
includes
five
free
circumcisions.
"Our
travel
agent
has
booked
you
to
officiate
at
our
daughter's
bat
mitzva...
She
wishes
to
wear
a
tallit
for
the
service
and
we
wish
to
purchase
this
item
in
Israel.
We
understand
that
in
an
area
called
'Meah
Shearim'
they
have
the
largest
selection
of
tallitot.
Do
they
also
carry
a
variety
of
female
tallitot
in
feminine
colors?"
You're
more
likely
to
find
this
item
in
Gaza
City.
"I
know
that
you
supply
the
candy
that
is
thrown
at
the
bar
mitzva.
Our
son
is
afraid
of
being
hurt
by
aggressive
candy-throwers.
Can
we
bring
marshmallows
from
the
States?"
May
I
suggest
felafel
balls.